Released October 5, 2005, Stephenie Meyer’s breakout book reached a level of fame and following near that of Harry Potter. Twilight, a dark romance novel, developed into a four-part book saga with five movies and one crazed cult of fans. The “Team Edward or Team Jacob?” question can still spark a heated debate over a decade later. Meyers thought up, wrote, and published Twilight in a matter of six months and simultaneously launched her career to unthinkable heights. In 2010, Forbes ranked her at 59th on their Celebrity 100—an annual list of the world’s highest-paid celebrities—with $40 million in earnings (this year, the 59th spot was shared by Garth Brooks, Jackie Chan and The Chainsmokers). Which is better: the book or the movie?
Movie (click title to see more)
If you couldn’t already tell that Twilight was a teen sensation, then this stat should. . .→
Book (click title to see more)
The book follows Isabella Swan (a.k.a. Bella), a teenager who moves to the dull town of Forks. . .→
× Twilight
Main characters Isabella Swan and Edward Cullen are played by Kristen Stewart (Zathura: A Space Adventure, Adventureland) and Robert Pattinson (Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix). While Stewart was quickly selected to play Bella, her counterpart was a little harder to find. The author’s ideal Edward had to easily convey the beauty and danger of the vampirical character. Meyers actually wanted the role to go to Henry Cavill (Superman. As in, the Superman), however, Pattinson fit the bill for a brooding, vampire-y guy, and here we are.
The movie remained fairly on track with the plot of the book, with minor adjustments to help the transition from page to screen. For example, Alice’s backstory is included in the book but skipped in the movie, and the Cullen family crest is absent from the books but included in the movie—not necessarily details that would ruin a film to a reader, or vice-versa. Critics were satisfied by the movie, but not moved by it. One reviewer, particularly unimpressed by the acting, stated that Stewart alternated between two expressions: “blank and slightly less blank.” Harsh, but not entirely wrong.
The book easily wins this round. With excellent reviews and an intriguing plot, Meyers’s novel gives fans a more exciting storytelling experience than her movie. The filming team definitely tried harder to make up for this disparity in the subsequent films, but as for Twilight, the book takes the cake.
LENGTH
U.S. GROSS
WORLDWIDE
GROSS
ROTTEN TOMATOES
RATING
If you couldn’t already tell that Twilight was a teen sensation, then this stat should show you the extent of it: At the 2009 Teen Choice Awards, the movie was nominated for 11 awards and won 10. It also won four 2009 Scream Awards, the Public Choice Award at the World Soundtrack Awards, two ALMA Awards, five 2009 MTV Movie Awards and two Grammy Award nominations.
× Twilight
The book follows Isabella Swan (a.k.a. Bella), a teenager who moves to the dull town of Forks, Washington, to live with her father. There, she meets the mysterious Edward Cullen, who sulks around school and seems to dislike her. One day, when a car almost hits Bella in the school parking lot, Edward stops the vehicle with only his hand. Bewildered, she begins to hear rumors that Edward and his family are actually vampires. When Edward saves her a second time, she uncovers the truth, and the two begin a lustful and dangerous relationship. When a rogue vampire tries to hunt Bella, the Cullen family protects her and saves her life yet again. As the book closes, Bella expresses her desire to become a vampire like her mysterious boyfriend, but having experienced the struggles of an immortal life, Edward refuses to turn her into his kind.
The book easily wins this round. With excellent reviews and an intriguing plot, Meyers’s novel gives fans a more exciting storytelling experience than her movie. The filming team definitely tried harder to make up for this disparity in the subsequent films, but as for Twilight, the book takes the cake.
Released October 5, 2005, Stephenie Meyer’s breakout book reached a level of fame and following near that of Harry Potter. Twilight, a dark romance novel, developed into a four-part book saga with five movies and one crazed cult of fans. The “Team Edward or Team Jacob?” question can still spark a heated debate over a decade later. Meyers thought up, wrote, and published Twilight in a matter of six months and simultaneously launched her career to unthinkable heights. In 2010, Forbes ranked her at 59th on their Celebrity 100—an annual list of the world’s highest-paid celebrities—with $40 million in earnings (this year, the 59th spot was shared by Garth Brooks, Jackie Chan and The Chainsmokers).
PAGE COUNT
AMAZON RATING
BOOK SALES